| Drew | Andy | Kyle | Jeb | |
| MaryChar | Lizzie | Katie | Carisa | Whitney |
| Brennan | Tate | Tom | Kara | Melissa |
| Andrea | Mollie | Amanda | Annie | Fauna |
| Jason | Lucas | Steve | Tyler |
| Kyler and Jeb | Drew and Tom | Andy and Jason | Kyle and Andrea |
| MaryChar and Lizzie | Katie and Fauna | Carissa and Steve | Whitney and Brennan |
| Amanda and Annie | Tate and Molly | Lucas and Tyler | Kara and Melissa |